LEADERSHIP Vs MANAGEMENT. The Difference between leadership and management. Fundamental Characteristics for a Leader to become a Great Leader.

December 16, 2009 by kutenk
Filed under: Leadership 

LEADERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT – RELATED YET FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT

Nowadays, everyone is a manager or has been a manager, and a new term has taken over the exalted position in the corporate vocabulary: ‘leader’.
Management was and is traditionally practiced from a top-down perspective. With all due respect for the underlings, but still … You develop your vision, mission, and strategy and impose it. Where practicable without resort to violence, and ideally with some measure of tact. A relatively simple procedure, within the grasp of nearly all primates.




But leadership is not so easily practiced. Because leadership – this is still widely misunderstood – works from the bottom up. You are a leader, not because someone appointed you, but because others see and accept you in that capacity. At many management training institutes these days Leadership Development is the most popular theme. But in truth, how often have we seen anyone become a leader as a result of such programs? In essence you can only be a leader and strive to become a better one. The most important condition for embodying leadership is, that others feel that you are not out there to take care of number one, but that you are there for them, or for something even more all-encompassing. In short that you stand for something which transcends your self-interest.

Leadership is closely related to management, but wholly different in fundamental aspects. The close relationship is caused by the fact that the one usually does not go without the other. To be effective, a manager needs to be a good leader. Equally, to be effective, a leader needs to be a good manager, or at least a passable one. In real life this combination is rare, because the qualities needed for leadership are so vastly different from the qualities needed for management that it is hard to master both in perfection. The difference is in the mental make-up:




Managers are good at directing people, making sure that they co-operate, that the things that need doing get done on time. Where necessary they rely on their status in the organisation – their power to hire and fire, humble or promote, create or crush careers – to achieve the set goals. The best of them deserve gold medals for drive and self-restraint. Leaders see opportunities beyond the horizon, dreams that might one day be realised, ideas too beautiful to relegate to the dustbin just because they seem unrealistic today. The best may not care much for medals, but are amply rewarded as they observe how their vision, fire and tenacity inspire those around them. They rely not on power, but on the respect in which they are held. Their relationship with co-workers is often highly personal and intense, and their demeanour may be chaotic and baffling at times – annoying even, but easy to forgive because of their palpable commitment.



Managers base their goals on what they deem necessary.
Leaders base their goals on what they deem desirable.

The difference between leadership and management was beautifully elucidated by Abraham Zaleznik in his famous article in the Harvard Business Review, ‘Managers and Leaders: Are They Different?’ Leaders, he said, are inspired, visionary people who are concerned with content, whereas managers are concerned with the process. Psychologically they have an entirely different reaction to order and chaos, and an entirely different concept of their role:



Managers
    hate chaos and in security
    tend to plunge into the process to sort things out and bring order
    strive for control and predictability
    find compromises
    try to find a workable solution as quickly as possible – often without having thought out all the ramifications of the situation
    do things right.

Leaders
    are highly tolerant of insecurity
    can live with lack of structure and even chaos for extended periods of time without becoming unduly stressed
    strive to inspire
    find reconciliations
    postpone decision-making till they have a clear picture of all aspects of the situation (like artists, experimental scientists and other creative thinkers)
    do the right things.

But for a leader to become a great leader, more is required than these instrumental differences. We trust that you have your own criteria to add, but these seem to be fundamental:
Great leaders
    pair leaders’ capacity to create something out of chaos with vision and passion
    inject the moral strength required to let their organisations play a role of importance in the world
    attain greatness less by doing than by being.

  • Share/Bookmark

Related posts:

  1. The Extraordinary Leader: Turning Good Managers into Great Leaders | by John H. Zenger and Joseph R. Folkman | 2009 | ISBN: 9780071628082. How to build Leadership Skills. Keys to Leadership Success and Failure. Leadership Development and Training
  2. Leaders Make the Future: Ten New Leadership Skills for an Uncertain World | by Bob Johansen | 2009 | ISBN: 9781605090023. Enduring Leadership Skills. A Leader with Strong Maker Instinct. Leaders with Great Clarity. A Leader with Strong Immersive Learning Ability
  3. The Strategic Project Leader: Mastering Service-Based Project Leadership | by Jack Ferraro | ISBN: 9780849387944. Project Leadership Development. New Project Leader Guide. Project Management Certifications. Strategic Project Management Offices. Project Management Competencies
  4. The Six Sigma Leader: How Top Executives Will Prevail in the 21st Century | by Peter Pande | ISBN: 9780071454087. Smart Leadership Principles. Leading with Facts and Data. Building Leadership Teamwork
  5. Characteristics of Leading Supply Management Organizations. Supply Chain Management.
  6. The Five Commitments of a Leader | by Mark Leheney | ISBN: 9781567262193. Leadership Books. Leadership Training. Personal Development. Professional Development.
  7. Key Elements that form the core of leadership.
  8. The Enlightened Leader: An Introduction to the Chakras of Leadership | by Peter Ten Hoopen and Fons Trompenaars | 2009 | ISBN: 9780470713969. LEADERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT. Creating CORPORATE PERSONALITY.
  9. Leadership Books. Women Lead the Way: Your Guide to Stepping Up to Leadership and Changing the World | by Linda Tarr-Whelan | 2009 | ISBN: 9781605091358. Transformational Leader. How To Make Women’s Power Visible.
  10. The Right Leader: Selecting Executives Who Fit | by Nat Stoddard and Claire Wyckoff | 2009 | ISBN: 9780470344507. Leadership Books. New Leadership Selection Strategy. Employee Hiring Process. Executive Leadership Training.
  11. Fundamental difference between Learning and Training.
  12. The Inspiring Leader: Unlocking the Secrets of How Extraordinary Leaders Motivate | by John H. Zenger, Joseph R. Folkman and Scott K. Edinger | 2009 | ISBN: 9780071621243. The Top 10 Uninspirational behaviors. Attributes of the Inspirational Leader
  13. 4 Qualities for Effective Counselor. Guide for Performance Counseling, Problem Counseling, and Individual Growth Counseling
  14. Leadership Books. Women Lead the Way: Your Guide to Stepping Up to Leadership and Changing the World | by Linda Tarr-Whelan | 2009 | ISBN: 9781605091358. Women Leaders guide to Transformational Leadership. Building a Community Women’s Network
  15. CFO Leadership Strategies: Industry Leaders on Financial Integrity, Compliance, and Best Practices | by Aspatore Books Staff | ISBN: 9781596222649. Successful Strategies and Characteristics of a CFO. Ensuring Financial Integrity and Compliance Success.
  16. The Introverted Leader: Building on Your Quiet Strength | by Jennifer B. Kahnweiler | 2009 | ISBN: 9781576755778. Cheap Discount Leadership Books. Tips for Building Successful Relationships. 4 P’s Action Plan.
  17. Servant-Leadership Across Cultures: Harnessing The Strength Of The World’s Most Powerful Leadership Philosophy | by Fons Trompenaars and Ed Voerman | 2009 | ISBN: 9781905940998. 7 Leadership Dilemmas. 7 Core Leadership Qualities. Can We Measure Integrity?
  18. The Manager’s Answer Book: Practical Answers to More Than 200 Questions Every Manager Asks | by Susan Benjamin | ISBN: 9781402210532. Management Books. Attributes of a Great Manager. Key Management Issues and Solutions.
  19. The Leadership Scorecard | ROI For Leaders | by Jack J. Phillips and Lynn Schmidt | ISBN: 9780750677646. Leadership Development Books. Leadership Program. Cheap Leadersip Books.
  20. The Little Black Book of Project Management, Third Edition | by Michael C. Thomsett | 2010 | ISBN: 9780814415290. Best Project Management Software. The Successful Project Manager. Business Process Management (BPM). Attributes of Project Leadership. Automated Project Management Systems
  21. It Takes a Lot More than Attitude…To Lead a Stellar Organization | by Stever Robbins | ISBN: 9780975481004. Organizational Development Books. Building Corporate Culture. Balancing Management and Leadership.
  22. Business Leadership In China: How to Blend Best Western Practices with Chinese Wisdom | by Frank T. Gallo | ISBN: 9780470823651. 7 Philosophical and Cultural Foundations of Chinese Leadership. Unique Leadership Competencies in China. Key Competencies for an Executive Leadership Coach.
  23. Leadership Books. Leadership in the Era of Economic Uncertainty: The New Rules for Getting the Right Things Done in Difficult Times | by Ram Charan | 2009 | ISBN: 9780071626163. Essential Leadership Traits.
  24. Coaching for Performance GROWing Human Potential and PurposeCoaching for Performance: GROWing Human Potential and Purpose: The Principles and Practice of Coaching and Leadership, Fourth Edition | by John Whitmore | 2009 | ISBN: 9781857885354. Transformation through Transpersonal Coaching. Leadership for High Performance.
  25. Leadership Books. Leading in Times of Crisis: Navigating Through Complexity, Diversity and Uncertainty to Save Your Business | by David L. Dotlich, Peter C. Cairo and Stephen H. Rhinesmith | 2009 | ISBN: 9780470402306. Whole Leadership Approach.
  26. Making a Difference by Being Yourself: Using Your Personality Type at Work and in Relationships | by Gregory E. Huszczo | ISBN: 9780891062233. MBTI Personality Type. Stabilizers (STs). Harmonizers (SFs). Catalysts (NFs). Visionaries (NTs)
  27. Strategy Power Plays: Winning Business Ideas from the World’s Greatest Strategic Minds | by Karen McCreadie and Tim Phillips | 2009 | ISBN: 9781906821173. Strategic Management Books. Qualities of a Successful Leader.
  28. Project Management for Designers and Facilities Managers, Third Edition | by Howard G. Birnberg | ISBN: 9781604270112. PROJECT DELIVERY SYSTEMS. STRATEGIC PROJECT MANAGEMENT PLAN. PROJECT DELIVERY METHODS. CHARACTERISTICS OF EFFECTIVE PROJECT MANAGERS.
  29. Lead, Sell, or Get Out of the Way: The 7 Traits of Great Sellers | by Ron Karr | 2009 | ISBN: 9780470402184. Productivity Tools for Sales Leaders. How to Ask Good Sales Questions. Creating Powerful Value Propositions.
  30. What Qualities Distinguish Greatness? What separates Great People from Average People? Be a Winners who establish the habits of discipline and risk taking.
  31. Three Characteristics of a Workplace that Values Learning
  32. Move to Greatness: Focusing the Four Essential Energies of a Whole and Balanced Leader | by Ginny Whitelaw and Betsy Wetzig | ISBN: 9781904838203. Driving Supercharges Business Performance. Creating High-Performing Teams and Organizations
  33. Fundamental Negotiation Principles for Business. Good Business Negotiation Strategies.
  34. The Third Circle: Interactions That Drive Results | by Max Isaac and Anton McBurnie | ISBN: 9780973515305. Team & Organizational Effectiveness. Sustaining Organizational Level Change. Prescriptive vs. Learning Models of Leadership. Different Leadership Styles.
  35. Coaching for Performance: GROWing Human Potential and Purpose: The Principles and Practice of Coaching and Leadership, Fourth Edition | by John Whitmore | 2009 | ISBN: 9781857885354. Transformation through Transpersonal Coaching. Motivation and Self-Belief Development.
  36. Explore the real value of learning. Understand the challenges to prove the strategic value of learning.
  37. ASTD’s Ultimate Performance Management: Training to Transform Performance Reviews into Performance Partnerships | by Jeffrey Russell and Linda Russell | 2009 | ISBN: 9781607283508. Performance Planning and Development. Performance Coaching. The Great Performance Management Cycle
  38. The Best Secrets of Great Small Businesses: Creative, Innovative and Cost-Saving Ideas from Great Business Minds | by Ray Silverstein | ISBN: 9781402207662
  39. Dynamic Strategy-Making: Real-Time Guidelines for the 21st Century Leader | by Larry E. Greiner and Thomas G. Cummings | 2009 | ISBN: 9780787996635. Strategic Management Books. Building a Strategic System. Facilitating Real-Time Business Strategy.
  40. Top 5 Project Management Office Functions

Tags: , ,

Comments

One Comment on LEADERSHIP Vs MANAGEMENT. The Difference between leadership and management. Fundamental Characteristics for a Leader to become a Great Leader.

  1. Our New Alert Profile is…. – Wednesday, December 16, 2009 … | Corporations Finance Wisdom on Wed, 16th Dec 2009 4:27 pm

    2. [...] LEADERSHIP Vs MANAGEMENT. The Difference between leadership and … [...]

Tell me what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

You must be logged in to post a comment.